Should a Christian Do Magic?
Membership Level› Guest
Author/Source: Karl Bastian, Robert Hill
Topic: Gospel Magic
Karl answers the question of "Christian Magic" and posts an article he often shares with others struggling with this creative form of teaching.
This article is offered for those concerned with the use of magic or a wizard in presenting the Gospel to kids. Below is a great article worth reading for those interested in healthy dialogue and honest Christian interaction rather than simply condemning or judging. But first I offer a few quick points:
- Kids NEVER attribute any supernatural power to a magician. I've had adults wonder if I had supernatural powers, and I've had to show how a trick was done to relieve their fears, but never a child. Kids know it is a 'trick' and are quick to yell "it's up your sleeve" or some otherwise silly theory as to how the illusion was done.
- Not all Christian magicians do this, but I always, even when in a wizard character, acknowledge to the children that only God can really do the impossible, but a magician can do things amazing to the eyes.
- The magic forbidden in the Bible is not the art of illusion. The Bible forbids calling on evil forces, spirits, or powers - and a magician never does. If something supernatural ever happened, it would probably give the magician a heart attack right on stage in front of everyone. He knows what is possible and impossible and that he can only make it LOOK like the impossible is happening. From his point of view, what he is doing is quite possible and easy, because he sees what is truly happening.
- Magic is not deceiving people; it is only deceiving the eyes, much like a trick picture or optical illusion. The audience is not being fooled. They are being challenged mentally as the reality is hidden from them, but they know full well that what they see has an explanation, even if they have no idea what it could possibly be.
- Paul encouraged us to be "all things to all people" so that they might be reached. Certainly this is not a license to sin, but it is a license to use things that interest people to engage their minds and hearts to a message they otherwise may not listen to—and few things engage and interest people as powerfully as a well done magic show!
- Magic tricks are simply object lessons with a lot of pizzaz and a good dose of amazement! We need to teach in ways that draw kids in. They understand that the magic of a Magic Show. is not the same magic that is in the occult.
- Yes, Harry Potter glorifies magic and while fairly wholesome itself (magic aside) has led kids toward other types of magic that are less wholesome. The issue here is not the term magic. It is the role of parents to be aware of what their kids are reading and watching and to help them distinguish between what is good and what is bad. To say anything with magic is bad is easy, but that simplistic approach to life does not equip them to be discerning when they get older. Teaching kids that things are either ALL good or ALL bad is dangerous. If they find one good version of something, then they have been trained to accept all versions of it, and that can be tragic! Kids need to be taught to judge each thing against Scripture, not against simple definitions that may not apply.
Here is an article you may find helpful:
Should a Christian Do Magic or Conjuring?
Doesn't the Bible forbid magic, fortune-telling, and ventriloquism? Is it right for a Christian to be involved in sleight of hand and illusion--aren't these instruments dishonest and deceptive?
A Problem of Vocabulary
First, let's get our terms defined. When the Bible (especially certain translations) uses the term "magic" (e.g. Exodus 22:14) or "sorcery" (Deuteronomy 18:11 et al.) or "ventriloquism" (e.g. Isaiah 8:19), it is clearly dealing with man's involvement in the supernatural, often with the collaboration of evil spirits. The context of the Bible prohibitions make it clear that God does not want man to dabble in games with the devil. Today's manifestations of these forbidden activities are such things as ouija boards, tarot cards, the occult, and horoscopes. The Christian has no business playing with these, since they open the door to demonic influence.
Let it be emphasized that no true Christian magician or ventriloquist is in any way involved in the use of supernatural powers.
A problem rises from the fact that certain words have two meanings. "Magic" has the meaning of witchcraft or sorcery, but the word also means sleight of hand and illusion, the surprising and fascinating modern entertainment medium. Obviously, the Bible is talking about the first of these meanings and not the second.
Etymologically, the word "ventriloquism" means "belly-talking." As used in the Old Testament, the word refers to fortune telling by means of reading the entrails of slain animals, or demon possession, wherein an evil spirit spoke through a human mouthpiece. Modern ventriloquists create the illusion that their voices come from another source, using this to entertain. Spectators unable to explain this skill misnamed the illusion "belly talking." Again, the Biblical prohibition has reference to one meaning of this word, but not the animation of puppets as is done in the modern entertainment medium. The first thing we must be sure of when dealing with Biblical prohibitions is that we understand what the Bible is in fact saying, so that we do not misapply the truth because of a confusion in vocabulary.
Confusion with the Supernatural
One could raise the objection that it is wrong for the Christian to do any performance that could so easily be misinterpreted as sinful by someone who doesn't know. Doesn't the Bible warn us to "avoid all appearance of evil"? (I Thessalonians 5:22) Couldn't innocent parlor magic or ventriloquism be easily confused with forbidden activity? In fact, a better translation of I Thessalonians 5:22 is "avoid every form of evil" or "avoid every kind of evil." In dealing with right and wrong, one must always be careful of appearances, but it is not the appearance that makes something right or wrong.
The emphasis on appearance is the essence of hypocrisy. If the issue were that Christians are to refrain from doing anything that looks like sin or could be misinterpreted by someone who does not know, then we would never be able to do anything with confidence. According to this thinking, Jesus was correctly rebuked for eating with publicans, for forgiving prostitutes, and for touching lepers. Certainly these actions confused many people, but the Son of God knew His mission and performed His ministry in spite of possible objections.
The Gospel magician could easily be confused with the secular entertainer, or worse, with the occultist, just as the Christian singer could be identified with the acid-dropping Satanist, or the preacher could be linked with the immoral talk-show host. Or we could insist that it is wrong for the Christian to read any magazine or paperback book, because immoral people publish sinful books and magazines. Do we believe that because of the sin of some broadcasters, there is no value in the ministry of broadcasting? Part of the issue is whether a godly performer should stop ministry he knows to be right, just because someone else might misjudge his motives or his methods.
Some Christians are very superstitious and assume that anything they cannot themselves understand and explain must be supernatural. Hence they see negative effects as being produced by demons, and every positive event must be a miracle of God. There is, however, great room for neutral events which can be used either for good or for evil.
Ministry by means of "Deception"?
Another objection is that it is not right for the Christian to use trickery in presenting the truth. No matter how you slice it, magic involves deceit (illusion). Of course, some "Gospel magicians" try to get around this objection by never actually saying their hand is empty when it isn't, but they say, "my hand looks empty." This skirts the issue, since the intent is for the audience to believe that the hand was empty (or that the bunny materialized from thin air, or that the red scarf actually turned white, etc.) The deceit was there, regardless of whether the performer told a lie with his words or with his actions. Here we must deal with the nature of truth. At any given time, a presentation of truth only represents a portion of reality.
I carry a photograph of my wife that everyone claims is a very candid likeness, yet it deceives in certain ways. For one thing, my wife is not black and white and gray; for another, she is more than two inches tall and is not flat. But the image abstracted by this photograph captures her expression and personality very honestly. It is an honest—though partial--representation of the truth. The issue is whether the Gospel magician conveys the impression that he is doing supernatural things, or whether he honestly acknowledges it's trickery.
After all is said and done, most people acknowledge that magical entertainers do not actually have supernatural powers. If the total presentation is an accurate representation of Biblical truth, the audience will be impressed with the message, and not dazzled by the possibility of humans doing superhuman feats.
A Biblical Basis for Gospel Magic
It is fine to say that doing Gospel magic is not wrong, but is it right? Is there a Biblical justification for using magic to present Scriptural or spiritual truths?
The first part of the argument comes from Jesus' own use of parables—visual aids. Matthew 13:34 indicates that in Jesus' teaching, He always used object lessons. Sleight of hand and illusion provide a way of presenting some very powerful spiritual messages in a visual way. When a dirty handkerchief—representing sin—is transformed into an egg, it makes a very striking illustration of the change God makes in a person's life when he trusts Christ. Magic tricks have power to gain and maintain attention.
The second part of a Biblical basis for Gospel magic is God's own use of the spectacular as an attention-getting device. He could have dealt with people without using the miraculous, but with Moses, He chose to use a bush that burned without being consumed; with Balaam, He used a talking donkey; with Joshua, He used a destructive trumpet blast to bring down the walls of Jericho; and with Belshazzar, He wrote on the wall with a giant hand.
Many of the prophets used spectacular attention-getting devices, such as shaving their heads, wearing a rotten garment, making a model of Jerusalem. And what a sight Jonah must have been, bleached from the digestive juices of the great sea monster, as he paraded through Nineveh proclaiming the judgment of God.
But perhaps most spectacular of all are the descriptions of the events surrounding the death and resurrection of Jesus. It could have happened without a lot of fanfare, but Christ's death was accompanied by darkness and earthquake. The resurrection was accompanied by a blast of light that left the guards stunned and dazed.
I have seen some very impressive and effective uses of "magic" to illustrate principles from the Scriptures. When sleight of hand and illusion are harnessed for the purpose of explaining Gospel principles, it can be very powerful from a psychological point of view.
Conclusion To wind up this brief treatment, let me make several practical suggestions about your own attitude toward "Gospel magic":
- Enjoy magic presentations. Don't worry about being fooled. You don't need to understand how every trick is done in order for it to be all right.
- Pray for the Christian magician. He wants to present Gospel truths in an effective way, without violating what is proper. It is easy to give in to the sins of pride and presumption. He needs your understanding and support. Praise God that He has given this performer opportunities to present a message at places where a preacher would never be able to speak.
- Seek God's mind. Be sympathetic and ask God to help you understand what attitude is right to have toward forms of ministry that you do not wholeheartedly understand or endorse. Realize that the same skill may not be best for everyone, but God can bless it and use it for His glory.
- If you continue to have reservations, work them out. Talk to your local Christian magician. He will be happy to discuss them with you!
Thanks for being open to consider some new ideas. I hope they have helped you to gain a new perspective. Read Acts 10:9-20 and rejoice that God opens the hearts and minds of His children who are ready to receive His messages.
"Whatever you do, in word or in deed, do all in the name of the Lord Jesus, giving thanks [and honor and glory] through Him to God the Father." Colossians 3:17